Ask Travel Ball Parents – Is it Time to Change Teams?


Welcome to this week’s edition of Ask Travel Ball Parents. Last Tuesday, we gave our take on what (not) to say to your player after a game.  Today’s dilemma is one that many of us who’ve been around for a few seasons can relate to.118

My 9-year-old son is one of the better players on his team and loves the game. However the team kind of stinks. He is one of only a few good players and one of the few willing to put in the work. I want to look for another team, but I don’t want him to miss out on playing with his friends. How do I balance what’s best for him now (playing with friends) with what’s best for him in the long run (playing with a better team with better competition)?

Team Dad

*Travel Ball Parents neither endorses nor opposes any of the responses below. (We’re Switzerland.)

danielle wheelerDon’t ever be afraid of switching to a team that is a better fit.  And what fits one year may not fit the next.  Kids develop physically and skillfully at different rates.  Teams can fold.  Coaches can move.  The point is…you will probably be on several teams over the next few years.  And that’s ok.  You and he will make friendships along the way.  Some will stick and some won’t.  But isn’t that true with everything?
With that said… be cautious. Find a team with a great coach that has a need for your son.  You invest a lot of time with these people… and possibly money. Make sure it is enjoyable for all you involved.  Go to a few practices; maybe be a guest player for a tournament.  Really do your research before committing. —–Danielle Wheeler, baseball mom, Glen Allen, VA

The first thing you need to decide is if he is playing for you or for the team/himself; who is this about?  Is he gedan schillacitting the necessary development from the coaching staff?  Is he having fun? If the answer is no then you need to find a new team.  At this age I find that the kids will play up or down to the level of the other kids on the team as well as their competition.

To be brutally honest, he is not going to play in the MLB so don’t treat it like he is going there. He will develop relationships with  new teammates so he won’t miss out on anything.  If you feel you are getting your money’s worth and he is still learning and developing as a player then leave him where he is.
                                                                   —–Dan Schillaci, baseball dad, Pleasanton, CA

lisa santa rita

Does your son recognize this team stinks?  If he does, you may want to get his opinion on how that’s effecting him.  What is your son’s goal or your family goal for the sport?  Is this long term or just a short term rec sport goal?  If short term and he wants to play with his friends then leave him there.  If he has a long term goal in mind and wants to get better and be more competitive, he needs to find another team where those players, families, and coaches have that same goal in mind.  If they are his friends, they will be friends on and off the field.  This is where it gets tricky…..some parents will feel abandoned by you, or think you are trying to be better than them.  Reality is that you and your family have different goals regarding baseball.  They either respect that or don’t.  Sadly that’s where you will find out who your son’s true friends are.  Going to another team doesn’t mean your son will miss out on playing with his friends. He will make new ones, maybe better ones that enjoy the sport as much or more than he does and may bring out the best in him to play to his full potential.      —–Lisa SantaRita, baseball mom, Houston, TX

This is a great question, and one that we have probably all faced at one time.  First, don’t worry too much, because other teams            Navigating Travel Baseball Book Coverwill be calling soon asking for your son to join their team, particularly if he is also a good pitcher.  Your son is only 9, and he will likely be playing baseball for a very long time, so don’t over think this too much.  In our experience, teams don’t start to get serious until 11-12U.
If your son doesn’t want to leave this team just yet, then I would honor his decision.  For now.

In the meantime, keep your eyes open for the teams in his age bracket that are well coached and play well together.  At some point, your son will get fed up with all the bad plays, and will want to move along.  If the team is as bad as you say, then it is likely that it won’t stay together much longer anyway, so your decision will be made for you.  Now, saying all this, if your son is being over used, or over pitched because the team is so bad, or if he comes home after games raging mad because he’s tired of losing and looking bad, then I would definitely consider moving to another team sooner.                           —–Tony Midea, baseball dad, author


Chrissy StewartThis is a hard one. Both of my sons have been in this position. They also wanted to play with their friends, and not go to an outside travel team. Truthfully it’s one season, you have a different group for all-stars, as well as fall ball if your league does in house. It gives him a chance to teach other kids skills and how to get better if the coach takes the right approach. Ultimately, your son has to be happy or he will not perform well regardless. So if you throw him on a team with all strangers, he doesn’t want to be there, will have a bad attitude and he will struggle as well.  I would say to stick it out and try to make the best of it, let your son enjoy playing with his friends and look forward to the next season.                                                              —-Chrissy Stewart, baseball mom, Highland, IN

alton mercer

At 9 years old your kid’s hard work is making him one of the better players.  Congrats! Now let him have fun playing with his friends.

When he turns 11-12, genetics will kick in and there is nothing you can do about it.  It kicks in more and more the older they get.  I see it all the time. If you sucked as an athlete while in school then your kid will be mediocre at best.
You’re asking a pretty selfish question so I’m going to assume you sucked.  It’s always the dads who never lettered in school that push their child the hardest. Your only hope is that your Baby Mama was a superstar in her younger days.  Then maybe your kid can compete on the higher level teams as he gets older.  For now, keep having fun with friends. —Alton Mercer, pro wrestler, softball dad, Madison, GA

Liz BlanksThe question here really isn’t what you want to do, but what your son wants to do this season.  If he’s enjoying playing with his friends, the coaches are nice, all the team parents get along, and you can grin and bear sitting through watching The Bad News Bears Redux every weekend, by all means – do it!  Meanwhile, take this time to research other teams and think about where he can try out, which teams offer the best player development, what kind of facilities the teams have, what kind of tournaments they play in, and who will be the best fit for your son’s personality and playing ability.  It’s not always a quick and easy choice, so while he’s having a blast with his friends you can be doing your homework and preparing for tryout time.
The other side of the coin is that your son’s baseball dreams might not match up with your own, and he might be perfectly happy playing at this level with no desire to change teams.  It happens.  My advice to you is enjoy that time on the weekends, watching him have fun with his friends even when the team is majorly blowing it, and make sure you stock your cooler up with the good stuff.  It helps.

No, seriously, give it a season and let him have a good time and then reevaluate what his baseball goals are.  Usually one year on a lackluster team is enough to drive a talented player to want to try and find another team, and by then you will have already done some research on teams and have ideas of a new direction for him.  Good luck!—–Liz Blanks, baseball mom, Chesterfield, VAIMG_1873

At 9 years old, it’s really all about the kid and what he wants to do. If he’s fed up with the team’s performance and wants to leave, then let it be his decision. If he does decide to change, wait until the end of the season or whatever length of time you’ve committed to the team.  —–Andrew Weight, 14u player



IMG_6703-e1442948853832-225x300Well… I certainly have had this happen before…Here’s the deal. You have to look out for #1 in travel ball. That is your SON. If he is going to play competitive baseball as a young boy, and is really good, then he will not get any better if he is with a stinky team. As far as the friends go, he will meet new friends on another team. That is a decision to be made by the parents, but, in order to better your son, let him go play for someone else and meet a whole new team of friends! You will NOT regret this, I promise.            —–Tracy Bridges, baseball mom, Tupelo, MS

Got a question for us? (We always keep it anonymous.) Message us on our Facebook page. 


Angela Weight

Founder and publisher of Travel Ball, Angela Weight is still a little shocked to be running one of the most popular youth sports parenting sites on the web. Click the ABOUT US tab to read her story.

One thought on “Ask Travel Ball Parents – Is it Time to Change Teams?

  • May 21, 2018 at 11:56 am

    Fellow Parents, I’m also having a dilemma! We just moved to a new town 2 years a go! I know every parent thinks that their son is a super star. That being said, my son is actually a great player. He has all the fundamentals down from attending year round baseball camps, and practices with his own “Baseball workout”. When given the chance he always rises to the occasion. The problem is these coaches {going on a second year} only give their own kids key spots and playing time. BTW they usually get slaughtered every game {mercy ruled}. I’ve met with the coaches and they started playing him at the end of last year”In fact he won tournament MVP” Now this year we’re back in the trenches. I did like the suggestion of having HIM speak with the coaches.Plan B is to move over to a different team. Problem is that their is not many other choices! What to do?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

Follow Travel Ball Parents

Get Travel Ball Parents in your Inbox